Everyone is answering about wearing a mask, when the poster clearly makes the point that they don’t have one. They can’t just poof it from the air. The answers are not helpful.
The question is about whether shallow breathing and nose or mouth breathing is better. It’s a very particular question. An interesting question.
Does anyone know, with real scientific knowledge, what the answer to this specific question is? Can anyone answer to the specific question?
I know that breathing through your nose is generally better than breathing through your mouth for the simple fact that your nose has special follicles that act as a filter. But honestly the eyes and nose are most sensitive to infection and that’s part of the reason people are suggesting masks. It’s to lower the number of mucus membrane vectors for infection.
Op is more likely to get sick, especially if the other sick person isn’t washing their hands and cleaning surfaces they touch, and limiting the amount of time touching their own mucus membranes.
But if you inhale through the mouth as the alternative, you’ll directly track the viral load to the lungs which also had mucus and the viral load would multiply there instead. So take your pick. At least the nasal passage has some defences.
Masks are suggested not for your own safety but for the safety of others… as you mentioned the eyes are quite sensitive to infection so masks on public transit aren’t an effort to keep germs in the air from getting to you - they’re an effort to prevent germs from getting in the air.
You didn’t hear that talked about much during the pandemic because, if we’re honest, most people are assholes… they’ll bear a minor inconvenience to keep themselves safe but couldn’t be assed to keep anyone else safe.
What a mask does do for you is to keep you from touching your mouth or face in general… that can be quite effective at reducing illness and, post-covid, I think we should all be more aware of doorknobs and other shared surfaces.
No offense but this was explained many a time during the pandemic, especially in relation to immunocompromised people. If op can’t mask I doubt there are any breathing techniques they can use to prevent them from getting sick. But cleaning anything they touch and washing their hands is as good a solution as any.
The question is about whether shallow breathing and nose or mouth breathing is better.
Doesn’t matter.
Think simple: One breath moves a few liters of air. Doesn’t fit into one nose or one mouth. It must flow through. You breathe maybe 30 times per minute.
Try to do it “shallow”? Just try it out for a whole minute and watch LOL. No, you need all the air, each minute.
Move all the air through the nose or through the mouth? The virus doesn’t care. The virus can get you through all your membranes.
Everyone is answering about wearing a mask, when the poster clearly makes the point that they don’t have one. They can’t just poof it from the air. The answers are not helpful.
The question is about whether shallow breathing and nose or mouth breathing is better. It’s a very particular question. An interesting question.
Does anyone know, with real scientific knowledge, what the answer to this specific question is? Can anyone answer to the specific question?
The mask replies are super frustrating, haha.
Is there something I’m missing? It wasn’t clear to me that he doesn’t have a mask or can’t get one.
I’m in the same boat as you. Maybe it was in a comment somewhere that used to be upvoted.
I believe that if OP had a mask in this situation, they would most likely wear it. So we should assume that they don’t have one
I know that breathing through your nose is generally better than breathing through your mouth for the simple fact that your nose has special follicles that act as a filter. But honestly the eyes and nose are most sensitive to infection and that’s part of the reason people are suggesting masks. It’s to lower the number of mucus membrane vectors for infection.
Op is more likely to get sick, especially if the other sick person isn’t washing their hands and cleaning surfaces they touch, and limiting the amount of time touching their own mucus membranes.
Tons of viruses replicate in your sinuses (like covid), so idk if nose breathing would be the right answer.
Really, flushing out your sinuses after exposure is the best option if you can’t wear a mask.
But if you inhale through the mouth as the alternative, you’ll directly track the viral load to the lungs which also had mucus and the viral load would multiply there instead. So take your pick. At least the nasal passage has some defences.
Masks are suggested not for your own safety but for the safety of others… as you mentioned the eyes are quite sensitive to infection so masks on public transit aren’t an effort to keep germs in the air from getting to you - they’re an effort to prevent germs from getting in the air.
You didn’t hear that talked about much during the pandemic because, if we’re honest, most people are assholes… they’ll bear a minor inconvenience to keep themselves safe but couldn’t be assed to keep anyone else safe.
What a mask does do for you is to keep you from touching your mouth or face in general… that can be quite effective at reducing illness and, post-covid, I think we should all be more aware of doorknobs and other shared surfaces.
No offense but this was explained many a time during the pandemic, especially in relation to immunocompromised people. If op can’t mask I doubt there are any breathing techniques they can use to prevent them from getting sick. But cleaning anything they touch and washing their hands is as good a solution as any.
deleted by creator
Doesn’t matter.
Think simple: One breath moves a few liters of air. Doesn’t fit into one nose or one mouth. It must flow through. You breathe maybe 30 times per minute.
Try to do it “shallow”? Just try it out for a whole minute and watch LOL. No, you need all the air, each minute.
Move all the air through the nose or through the mouth? The virus doesn’t care. The virus can get you through all your membranes.
You breathe 12-20 times per minute, not 30. Average breath is under 0.5 liters, not a few liters.
Please don’t comment misinformation and pretend you have any idea what you’re talking about.